Short answer
Should I sell my high-mileage car or keep driving it?
Sell when repair bills climb faster than the car's value or safety becomes a concern. We buy high-mileage cars that still run, tow them for free and pay at pickup. Send the year, make, model, mileage and title status for an offer.
A car with 220,000 miles on it that still starts every morning sits in an odd middle ground. It is not dead, but it is not worth much repair either. Matteson Cash For Junk Cars Inc buys these cars, running or not, so you can decide on your terms.
What decides the offer on a worn-out car that runs
- Weight and size. A tired full-size sedan outweighs a tired compact.
- Condition of the body. Rust through the rocker panels or floor pans signals the end of the road, but the metal still counts.
- What still works. Engine, transmission, glass and wheels all matter. The fact that the car runs is a plus, since it can move under its own power.
- Catalytic converter. Still on the car is the goal.
- Title status. A clean title in your name keeps things simple. Read about no-title cars if you lack one.
- Mileage. It is part of the picture, but a high number alone does not rule out an offer.
When to sell instead of repair
A few signs point the same direction:
- A repair quote that equals or exceeds what the car sells for on the road.
- Repeated repairs. The third repair in a year usually signals more are coming.
- Safety failures. Bad brakes, a rotted frame or a steering problem are not worth chasing on an old car.
- Failing emissions. In the Chicago area, some cars must pass an emissions test to renew registration. Fixing a failed test on an old car can cost more than selling it. See the repair or junk guide for the full comparison.
- A big upcoming cost. Timing belt, transmission or head gasket on a car with little life left.
If none of these apply, keep driving. If two or three do, request an offer and compare.
Prepare your car
- Write down the exact odometer reading.
- List any known problems honestly: warning lights, noises, leaks.
- Gather the title, keys and your ID.
- Remove your plates, toll transponder and personal items.
- Leave the converter, battery and wheels on the car.
What pickup looks like
You show up with the keys and papers. The driver confirms the car matches your description, checks the title, and loads it. A running car is the easiest kind to load, since it can be driven onto the truck or rolled easily. You pay nothing for the tow and get paid when the truck loads up. Same-day pickup is sometimes open, depending on how full the day is. The how we buy cars page covers the steps in order.
Why selling before a breakdown works out better
A car that dies on the highway or in a parking lot adds a tow, a missed day and an urgent decision. A car you sell while it still runs gives you time to compare options. You can also read what is my junk car worth before you commit.
Mistakes to avoid
- Spending on a repair the week before selling. New parts rarely raise a junk offer enough to cover the cost.
- Rolling back or hiding the mileage. Odometer fraud is a federal and state offense, and sellers sign an odometer statement.
- Cancelling insurance first. Keep coverage until the car leaves.
- Clearing warning codes to look healthy. Be honest about the lights.
- Waiting until registration expires. A renewal bill on a car you plan to sell is wasted money.
If your car no longer runs, look at cars that won’t run. For SUVs and pickups with big mileage, see trucks, SUVs and vans. We buy in Oak Forest, Tinley Park, Homewood and nearby suburbs.
Send the details
Use the offer form to share the year, make, model, mileage and any known problems. We call back, and once you agree, we set the pickup.
More questions
Is there a mileage that makes a car unsellable?
My car still runs. Do I need to wait until it dies?
Does a rolled-back or broken odometer matter?
What if the check engine light is on?
Similar situations
Guides for this sale
- Is My Car Worth Fixing? When to Junk a CarThe 50 percent rule, repair patterns and safety signs that tell you when to junk a car instead of fixing it.
- How Much Is My Junk Car Worth? What Sets the OfferThe six things that actually move a junk car offer, and how to describe your car so the number holds.
Towns we tow from
- Oak ForestFree towing for junk cars in Oak Forest, a Cook County city north of Matteson near I-57 and 159th Street.
- Tinley ParkFree towing in Tinley Park, a big village with its own overnight, snow and abandoned-car rules.
- HomewoodFree towing in Homewood, with the village's inoperable-car, alley and overnight rules explained.


